All insight Logo
Happy black mother holding little daughter outside car

Top 10 Auto Insurance Companies

Picture of Kattia Zambrano

Kattia Zambrano

All-Insight Icon
All-Insight Icon

Jump to:

Organizations Vetted
0
Hours Researching
0
Features Reviewed
0
All-Insight Top Picks
0
It's impossible to foresee an automobile accident. Auto insurance provides you with peace of mind while you're driving and protects you from a lawsuit. We've examined cost, coverage, and claims processes to determine the industry's top companies.

1.    Geico

Rating: 5 out of 5.

There are several reasons why Geico has become one of the most popular auto insurance companies in recent years. According to those who are considered to be among the top-5 auto insurance providers, as well as those who think that Geico is the best auto insurance provider around, Geico is one of the best auto insurance providers around.

It’s clear that Geico has one of the highest customer satisfaction ratings of all auto insurance providers. Clients seem to be happy and customer service is rated as above-average when compared to other insurance providers.

Geico’s website is one of the most user-friendly websites out there – especially in the auto insurance industry. Their website makes it easy for prospective customers to learn about policies and plans, and for existing customers to access their information, file claims, track progress, pay bills, and so much more. Not to mention, they even offer their very own dedicated mobile app, which certainly makes a world of difference for those who have a mobile-first mentality.

The bottom line with Geico is quite clear – the good outweighs the bad. Geico is a great auto insurance provider and they offer a variety of plans, policies, and coverages to ensure that you and your family of drivers are safe and protected on the road.

2.    CarInsurance.net

Rating: 5 out of 5.

CarInsurance.net is owned by Assurance IQ, LLC, a fully licensed auto insurance agency located in Bellevue, Washington. Assurance is certified by the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and has an A+ rating.

This online platform was created to help anyone searching for auto insurance to quickly compare policy coverage options and pricing across multiple insurance providers. The website contains a comparison form, contact page, and terms and conditions information.

CarInsurance.net doesn’t actually offer insurance, what you get after you answer all of the questions is an aggregate list of insurance companies and the expected rates you’ll find, in a sense, helping you from having to go to every company’s website to answer the same questions over and over again.

But we found that it is a great way to ensure that you find a pretty good deal overall.

3.    Erie Insurance

Rating: 4 out of 5.

According to JD Power’s rankings, Erie Insurance is the finest company for purchasing automobile insurance. Erie is present in 12 states, including Washington, DC. Because Erie has a more limited customer base than companies like Geico, Progressive, and others, it concentrates on developing long-term relationships.

Accident forgiveness, travel expense coverage, pet injury coverage, glass repair without a deductible, locksmith services, and other perks and add-ons are just some of the benefits and coverage Erie offers. Long-term price stability is also an option when you get your auto insurance from them.

It’s true; there aren’t many complaints regarding Erie. Although you won’t get a dedicated mobile app, you’ll receive exceptional service, extensive coverage options, a lot of benefits, and the ability to lock in your rate, all of which will be worth it.

4.    Travelers Insurance

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Travelers has been in the business for over 150 years and employs a large number of independent agents with local expertise, making it a great option for customers seeking comprehensive and reasonably priced coverage. Other insurers are unable to provide discounts and supplemental add-ons at as diverse a range.

Despite receiving middle-of-the-pack ratings from consumer rating organizations, Travelers has received an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau. The website is clean and well-organized, which makes signing up for coverage fairly simple.

Many states have a minimum liability limit, but beyond that, you can customize your coverage to suit your needs. Travelers offers some less common discount options in addition to industry-standard multi-policy and good payer discounts. Furthermore, you can save up to 10% if you get a quote before your current policy ends.

5.    Liberty Mutual Insurance

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Liberty Mutual provides no-nonsense vehicle insurance. All of Liberty Mutual’s basic automobile insurance policies include industry-standard security and protections, as well as two or three add-ons.

Not only is getting a quote from Liberty Mutual easy if you’ve never purchased insurance before, it also takes less than 10 minutes and shows you how much your policy would cost before you buy it.

You can purchase insurance online through Liberty Mutual’s local offices, but if having a connection with an agent or representative is important, you can do so as well.

Rates are one of Liberty Mutual’s biggest drawbacks, as they can range from being the cheapest to the most expensive option depending on where you live. Even with a number of Liberty Mutual’s discounts, its prices can still be quite high in comparison to its peers.

6.    MetLife

Rating: 4 out of 5.

MetLife is one of the most established insurance firms, with a large network of agents and a wide variety of services. In addition to its standard features, MetLife’s long-term policies help it stand out from the crowd.

MetLife Auto & Home offers comparable coverage options and rates as its competitors. If you have your vehicle repaired through one of MetLife’s preferred service providers, MetLife guarantees ‘quality repairs,’ which typically means using original manufacturer parts.

Nearly all drivers can get coverage from MetLife, but you may not receive the same level of personalized service when filing a claim that you might with a smaller, more specialized auto insurance firm, which may account for some of the dissatisfaction.

7.    State Farm

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Those searching for an insurance provider that can offer a variety of car and home coverages should consider State Farm. State Farm is an above-average insurance firm that provides a variety of insurance products. State Farm’s renters insurance is particularly well-suited for renters in general. Those desiring a more personalized experience with an insurance agent in their local area are likely to find what they want.

State Farm’s home and automobile insurance program received a bad evaluation because its rates were less competitive than those of direct insurers such as Esurance and GEICO.

When compared to its rivals, State Farm renters insurance has a more attractive price. These rates don’t account for State Farm’s discounts for eligible clients. Those seeking State Farm’s greatest bargains can still receive wonderful value.

State Farm provides the best of both worlds to insurance shoppers seeking a local agent relationship or an all-online experience.

Customers who prefer to manage their insurance independently can take advantage of State Farm’s mobile app Pocket Agent. This app, which has received favorable comments from its users, allows you to pay your premiums, submit a claim, and get roadside assistance.

8.    USAA

Rating: 3 out of 5.

USAA offers superb rates for car and home insurance to its policyholders. People with more expensive homes might particularly benefit from USAA’s low homeowners insurance premiums. Young drivers especially can benefit from selecting USAA for car insurance.

USAA provides excellent customer service, as indicated by its high ratings for claims satisfaction and low rate of complaints for all of its insurance products.

A USAA policy provides 60% off storage rates for active military members while they are deployed. There are few downsides to mention. USAA customers typically interact with their insurer exclusively online, since USAA has few physical locations and they are mostly located near military bases.

Furthermore, USAA has stringent eligibility requirements and those who do not fit into one of the groups are unable to obtain a policy. Only two categories of people are eligible for coverage: people who have served in the military, and people whose immediate family members have had USAA insurance.

9.    Direct Auto Insurance

Rating: 3 out of 5.

Direct Auto Insurance operates in 11 southern states and specializes in providing coverage to high-risk drivers with poor driving records or low credit scores. In exchange for a variety of rewards, customers may benefit from opportunities for safe drivers, good students, policy renewals, and senior citizens.

Direct Auto’s auto insurance plans feature fairly industry-standard protections. Liability and comprehensive coverage are included. Accidental death coverage, rental reimbursement, roadside assistance, and towing reimbursement are among the other options.

Direct Auto Insurance offers dependable protection and plenty of reductions, but it has received an excessive quantity of customer service issues. Those suffering from high-risk driving and striving to get a low-cost policy with another company would be best suited for it.

10. Amica

Rating: 3 out of 5.

It’s rare for an insurer to offer both low rates and excellent customer service. Even without discounts, Amica is an economical alternative for automobile insurance. And you may obtain even greater savings if you are able to utilize its discounts.

Amica’s car insurance rates are said to be some of the best, in addition to their agents’ and policyholders’ expertise and friendliness. In light of the negative reviews, we believe Amica has some of the best ratings we’ve seen in the insurance industry.

Amica and GEICO both provide some of the lowest rates available, making them a good option if you want to save money on your car insurance. Amica, despite not having the greatest discount deals, still outperforms other car insurance providers in other areas.

All-Insight Research Team:

Professional positive redhead young European woman works on freelance
Man talking through a headset
Planning new business strategy.
All insight Logo

Our team of researchers has done the legwork to compare providers so that you may make an informed choice, recognizing the pros and cons of each choice.

We receive referral fees from partners. Advertising Disclosure

All-Insight

Research and Compare

Subscribe to our free newsletter